Shopping for “Skinny Girl” Jeans
Tuesday, December 30th, 2008I felt as if I were living an episode of TLC’s “What Not To Wear”: http://tlc.discovery.com/fansites/whatnottowear/whatnottowear.html. I made my 11-year-old daughter promise NOT TO WEAR anything from her collection of over-sized novelty t-shirts (mostly men’s size large, compliments of a much traveled aunt) and return ALL of my old Levi 501s (size 28/34…about a women’s 6, and she’s a 00!). In exchange, I promised her a “new wardrobe” of fitted yet age-appropriate t-shirts and new jeans in her size.
At just over 11 and 1/2, my daughter, Reiley, is 5′4″ and about 90 lbs. soaking wet. A year ago, XL tops in the girls’ section left over two inches of her belly bare when she raised her arms; between the time school started in August and now, she outgrew a girls’ size 16 pants/skirt in length. We’ve been struggling to find clothes SHE feels comfortable wearing, I approve of, and fit into the kids’ clothing budget. Until VERY RECENTLY, Reiley refused to wear “teenager” clothes in favor of hand-me-downs. Hence the too-big tees and Levis.
After successfully removing her tees to a closet drawer, we started replacing them with “long” tees in XXL/16-18 when we could find them and women’s size XS otherwise. We were doing really well filling Reiley’s closet by Christmas; Santa and Grandma sent us over the top. So we focused on jeans when we set out December 26th.
At that point, Reiley already had ONE pair of jeans we both like: a size 00/24 “boyfriend” cut Lucky Brand Jeans in very faded, distressed denim. So we started there.
Personally, I LOVE Lucky Brand Jeans: http://www.luckybrand.com/. They’re well-made and reasonably priced. The low-rise “Little Maggie” fits perfectly over my nearly non-existent hips. I can wear the regular length with flip flops and sneakers, the long length with heels. Unfortunately, we couldn’t find a pair EXACTLY like Reiley’s favorites. But we did find a “Sundown Straight” ($51.75) that came close – a little lower cut and tighter than she’s used to in a 00, but really cute. She also liked a “retro” cut that was only available in a 0 with a bit more “hip” than she actually has, so we put those on hold and moved on.
Since Reiley LOVES classic Levis, we hit the Levi outlet store next: http://us.levi.com/home/index.jsp. There were no 501s in a 24, and I wasn’t about to let her try the larger, baggier sizes. So we moved to the “women’s” side of the store and she tried every “skinny” and “straight” style in stock in a 00 or 0. She liked the 504s best ($31). Much like the “Skinny 503″ that is among my own favorites, the Levi 504 is a “slouch” jean, meaning that it is low rise in front, but markedly higher in back to prevent pantie peek-a-boo. It fit a little tighter than the Lucky Jeans, so we decided on the 0 in a faded indigo wash.
Next up: Seven for All Mankind. We looked. We touched. We agreed that there was no way an 11-year-old needed jeans at roughly $75.00 each on sale!
Finally, we tried Guess: http://shop.guess.com/?CMP=KNC-reprisegoogle2008&HBX_PK=guess&HBX_OU=50. Reiley was against it. As far as she is concerned, Guess is dangerously close to the Abercrombie and Fitch, American Eagle, and Hollister “everyone at school” wears, and so maybe too “girlie girl” for her. I told her that I used to wear Guess when I was much less the fashionista than I am now, and reminded her that my close friend and stylist refers to Guess as “skinny girl” jeans. It might be perfect for her.
My logic prevailed. We both tried the straight cut “Malibu,” a “skinny jean,” and the low-rise “Doheny” jean with patch pockets. Reiley thought that the skinny jean was too much like the Levis, and the Doheny showed too much skin. But she LOVED the Malibu. No wonder, it looks just like her favorite Lucky’s.
The moms reading this will appreciate that, on me, that same jean didn’t look quite as terrific and prompted Reiley to remark, “Mommy, you have not butt!” in the same disgusted tone that her older brother once told me, “Mom, I wish YOU had a cool car like Uncle Danny!” as we washed the MINIVAN he and his siblings were responsible for bringing into my life…
Anyway, we bought the Guess jeans ($49) she liked to make four. In addition to the black skinny jeans she got for Christmas and a pair of Roxy jeans that – miraculously – still fit, I think she’s in good shape.












